Jewelry Guide

Which Pink Gemstone Should I Choose for My Engagement Ring?

Affiliate Disclosures

As Jewelry Shopping Guide  editors, we write about things that we love and we think you’ll like too. We often have affiliate partnerships, and may generate some revenue from these links at no cost to you.

Pink gemstones make beautiful engagement rings, as they are different and feminine. Pinks tend to go with any skin tone as well, and depending on the shade you choose, can stand out or blend in quietly. Pink symbolizes love, understanding, compassion and tenderness, all ideal traits for a blossoming relationship.

There are many pink gemstones to pick from if you decide you want a pink engagement ring. However, not every gemstone is meant to be worn every day so knowing the pros and cons will help you make the right gemstone choice.

Here we cover the best, the good and the not so great pink gemstones for your engagement ring.

Recommended Pink Gemstones

  1. Pink Diamond Engagement Rings

Pink diamonds are among the rarest variety of diamonds. They are extremely rare and expensive and hard to come across. The best pink diamonds come from the Australian Argyle mine and can cost hundreds of thousands per carat. These gemstones come in a range of shades, from very faint to vivid. The more saturated and vivid the color, the more valuable the stone.

Pink Diamond

A fancy vivid purplish pink diamond. See more pink diamonds from James Allen here.

A great alternative is a synthetic pink diamond. A synthetic diamond is optically, chemically and physically similar to its mined counterpart and can be up to 90% less expensive. Synthetic and mined pink diamonds are very difficult to tell apart, and often only experts would be able to tell a synthetic gemstone from a mined one using special tools.

If you want a pink diamond without the exorbitant cost, we suggest going for a synthetic stone. However, some may say that it lacks the romance and the mystery of a stone that’s been created over millions of years deep within the ground. On the flip side, others may appreciate that there is no environmental or ethical impacts with synthetic stones as there is with mined stones.

Note that synthetic pink diamonds are still relatively expensive due to the labor-intensive and expensive process required to create them. If purchasing online, are known for being the best in the business and they even have exclusive access to Argyle Pinks, meaning that you’ll see some pretty spectacular pieces on their site that you won’t find anywhere else. For more affordable stones, check out James Allen. For synthetic pink diamonds, you can check Brilliant Earth or Amazon.

  1. Pink Sapphire Engagement Rings

The next best pink stone is a sapphire which is highly durable, scratch resistant and tough, making it ideal for daily wear. Pink sapphires are an affordable alternative to pink diamonds and are usually even less expensive than blue sapphires.

Pink sapphire engagement ring

A high quality pink sapphire in a diamond halo ring. See it here.

Pink sapphires in halo settings are the most popular, as the little ring of diamonds add a sparkle and brilliance which the sapphire does not have. It also acts as a buffer and protects the gemstone. If you want less pink and more brilliance, why not opt for a pink sapphire halo surrounding a colorless diamond.

Pink sapphires can be found in a variety of shades, with the shade known as hot pink being the most popular. This is due to its intense shade of pink and vibrant appearance. A pink sapphire that is bordering on red may be classified as a ruby, as rubies are, to put it simply, red sapphires. As with diamonds, an environmentally friendly option is to choose a created pink sapphire. This would come at a fraction of the cost and is a practical option.

To learn more about pink diamonds and pink sapphires, check out this article.

Morganite – Wear with Care

Morganites have become very popular of late and are loved for their soft, feminine hue. They come in soft pinks, and are rarely found in statement shades. Morganite pairs beautifully with rose gold as the two colors complement each other. You can sometimes find yellow gold morganite rings but these are unique and quite eye-catching.

Pink morganite engagement ring

An elegant morganite ring from Blue Nile. See this ring here.

If you opt for a morganite ring, take care to take off the ring before engaging in any strenuous activities. For example, always take off the ring before gardening, swimming or doing any sports. This precaution is necessary as the surface of the gemstone can be scratched and scuffed easily and may eventually dull and lose its sparkle. Also, having the morganite set in a protective setting such as bezel or halo will add another layer of protection for your ring.

Read more about morganite here.

What about Other Pink Gemstones?

There are a host of other gemstones such as pink tourmaline, pink topaz, pink spinel and so on. These are just as beautiful as diamonds and sapphires but unfortunately, are not as durable. Most jewelers prefer not to work with gemstones other than sapphires, rubies and diamonds when it comes to engagement rings. This is because these gemstones are ideal for daily wear and can withstand rough exposure without damage.

Having said that, you can have literally any type of gemstone in your engagement ring, as long as you choose a protective setting and adjust the maintenance required to reflect the gemstone’s hardness and durability. In some cases, such as with pearl or opal rings, you will have to have the gemstone replaced every so often.

Jewelry Guide