Jewelry for Your Girlfriend’s Birthday – A Quick and Handy Guide

Affiliate Disclosures

As Jewelry Shopping Guide editors, we write about things that we love and we think you’ll like too. We often have affiliate partnerships, and may generate some revenue from these links at no cost to you.

Jewelry makes an excellent gift for your girlfriend’s birthday. Most girls love jewelry and whatever her style or taste in fashion, you can always find something that she will love. A piece of jewelry shows that you’ve put thought into the gift, however, finding a meaningful birthday jewelry gift can be difficult.

JamesAllen Engagement Rings

We’ve got you covered!

Here’s what you need to consider to pick the perfect jewelry for your girlfriend’s birthday.

How Long Have You Been Together?

The length of your relationship correlates to the type of jewelry you purchase. Note that the advice given below is not gospel but is just a guide to give you some pointers. You can set your budget to suit your situation.

If You’ve Been Together Just a Few Weeks

Choose: Choose costume jewelry and trending pieces.

Budget: Approx. $30

If your relationship is quite new, there’s no need to splurge on an expensive piece of jewelry. At this stage, you may even be wondering if you need to buy her a birthday gift.

However, it’s always nice to make the gesture and show her that you can be thoughtful. And if you want to impress, you’ll definitely score points by buying a gift. You can find beautiful pieces at the local department store and online on sites like Amazon.

Going Steady for Several Months

Choose: Premium materials, quality pieces

Budget: Approx. $100 to $200

White moonstone cabochon ring
White moonstone cabochon ring by Blue Nile. See it here.
gold ball earrings
Gold bead ball earrings by Blue Nile. See them here.

By now, your relationship has probably gotten more serious and you both know each other well. You will be expected to buy a meaningful, carefully chosen gift. Think jewelry along the lines of a mid-range, high-quality piece made of premium materials, like semi-precious gemstones and gold plating.

Going Strong for Years

Choose: Fine jewelry and precious metals

Budget: Approx. over $200

Garnet Birthstone Necklace
Stunning red garnet necklace by James Allen. See it here.
Emerald Cut Diamond Earrings
Emerald cut diamond earrings by James Allen. See them here. 
Vintage Green Sapphire Ring
Vintage green sapphire engagement ring by Luo Jewelry. See it here.

By this stage, you are probably really good at gauging what your girlfriend likes and what she gravitates towards. It’s important to put thought and effort into your birthday gifts now and it’ll be expected of you. Think of fine jewelry pieces that she will wear again and again. A designer watch or smart jewelry are some great ideas too.

What Is Her Personal Style?

Some girls like big, loud jewelry while others like small, minimalist pieces. Some may like color and gemstones, while others prefer jewelry of precious metals only. Some lean towards quirky, unique pieces, while others like what is trending at the moment.

Lost and confused?

Take note of what your girlfriend usually wears. What type of jewelry does she usually wear? This will give you ideas as to what to opt for.

However, don’t be afraid to express yourself through your gift too. Maybe she might just fall in love with the piece you’ve chosen even if it’s not something she would normally have chosen for herself.

Consider Her Age

Pick a piece that suits her age. Some pieces of jewelry are made for a more mature age category. This generally includes formal, elaborate fine jewelry. Other pieces are ideal for a more youthful audience. Again, draw inspiration from what she normally wears to help you decide on the piece.

Many online retailers have whole sections dedicated to birthday jewelry. Browsing through these collections should give you some inspiration as to what to choose for your lady. Here are some popular styles for birthday jewelry gifts:

1. Birthstone Jewelry

After all, it is her birthday, and what better way to indicate it than with birthstone jewelry? Choose a piece that corresponds with her birth month, taking care to consider size and style. In general, you’ll find that birthstone jewelry is often crafted into casual styles and smaller sizes, suitable for daily wear.

If your lady’s birth month is in April (diamond), May (emerald), July (ruby), or September (sapphire), your pocket could take a hit as these are the most expensive gemstones out there.

Ruby and Diamond Drop Pendant
Emerald-Cut Ruby Drop Pendant by Blue Nile. See it here.

To work around this, you could opt for jewelry made of synthetic/lab-created versions of these gemstones.

You could also opt for small stones rather than large, central ones. This would still be pricier than lab-created rubies, but your girl may love it more than a large lab-created one.

2. Customizable Jewelry

This includes pendants, bracelets, and rings that can be engraved.

Engraved Letter Pendant Necklace
Custom Engraved Letter Pendant Necklace by Caitlyn Minimalist. See it here.

It’s your chance to show how thoughtful and amazing you are by choosing the perfect quote or concept to engrave. You could opt for both your initials (a little cheesy but a classic), a funny quote or some meaningful poetry, a Bible verse… whatever floats your boat.

floral locket for girlfriend's birthday
A stylish floral locket that is sure to delight any girl. See it here

You can also pick a locket for your pictures. While this might sound corny, it’s a lovely gesture and one bound to be loved and cherished forever.

Final Words

Hopefully, this guide has given you some inspiration on what to purchase for your lady. Buying jewelry is always difficult as there’s so much thought that needs to go into it, plus if you are plonking down a large sum for the gift, you want to make sure it takes her breath away.

If you are searching online, we recommend checking out Blue Nile’s extensive Birthstone and Engravable collections.

James Allen also has an impressive collection of Jewelry Gifts at a range of prices and styles.

For a more detailed look into buying jewelry for her in general, check out our guide.

Jewelry Guide