8 Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings in San Francisco

Affiliate Disclosures

San Francisco is one of the most quintessential American cities. It’s brimming with coastal beauty, urban architecture, and energy. The city is steeped in history while simultaneously shaping the future. It’s this patchwork of old and new, nature and civilization that inspires countless jewelry designers and curators to bring the Bay Area a dazzling collection of engagement rings to suit any style.

This is why picking the best from this large number of engagement ring stores is quite tricky. For this list, we looked at each jeweler’s unique selling points, range and quality of products, customer reviews and the customer service they offer. 

Ready to dive in? Here’s our list of the 8 best places to buy engagement rings in San Francisco.

Shreve & Co.

Location: 150 Post St, San Francisco, CA 94108

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Shop For: Fine jewelry from around the world in a historic, high-end, flagship store

Shreve & Co. has called San Francisco home since the 1850s, where the company established itself as the finest silver and goldsmiths in America during the gold rush era. Shreve’s pieces were sought after by tycoons, establishment families and politicians with some historic pieces featuring in museums and private collections worldwide.

Shreve & Co. Continue to serve those looking for the finest jewelry, including stunning custom engagement rings made in-house by their experienced team. The collection also includes rings by renowned designers such as Fire and Ice Diamonds, Mikimoto Pearls and Furrer Jacot.

The flagship store is located between Union Square shopping district and the financial district and is an experience in itself. The luxe interior is a marvel. Couple that with fine jewelry from around the world, and knowledgeable staff and you have yourself a prestigious local classic.

La Bijouterie

Location: Suite #100, 388 Market St, San Francisco, CA 94111

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Shop For: Ethical diamonds set in bespoke designs with highly personalized service

La Bijouterie is a family-owned high-end jewelry store that prides itself on high-quality designs that use ethical diamonds and gemstones. For three generations, La Bijouterie has been designing made-to-order jewelry that captures each person’s unique style and taste. This is the place to go to if you’re after a reasonably priced custom design engagement ring.

The process is extensive and involves the wearer at almost every step – from initial ideas, sketches, and 3D modeling. The result is a completely unique ring that’s truly personal. La Bijouterie are known for their exceptional customer service, ensuring that you’re satisfied with the end result. They stand behind their products, spending time with each client on even the smallest details.


Noe Valley Gallery: 4089 24th St. San Francisco, CA 94114 

Pacific Heights Gallery: 2115 Fillmore St. San Francisco, CA 94115

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Shop For: Unique, bohemian engagement rings

Gallery of Jewels began as a way for jewelry designers Bill Hoover and Dona Taylor to showcase their own line. Since the 1990s, it has grown into a gorgeous marketplace of unique jewelry where artists can showcase their collections to clientele searching for something a little different.

Both the Noe Valley Gallery and the Pacific Heights Gallery display a diverse array of designers, each with their own style. The collection in each store differs slightly to reflect the neighborhood that surrounds it – making it the perfect spot to find a locally inspired engagement ring.

This makes a visit to either store a truly unique experience which is akin to walking into a treasure chest filled with exceptional jewels. Engagement rings found at the Gallery of Jewels stores are far from classic. Expect fine pieces inspired by ancient techniques and cultures; colorful gemstones mixed in with brilliant diamonds and unique rings that feel edgy, individual and always beautiful.

A meander through the Gallery of Jewels will lead you to designers that include Anouk Jewelry, Harika and Corey Egan. And if you don’t know where to start Bill, Dona and their friendly staff are ready and willing to impart their knowledge of the designs to you.

RTL Fine Jewelry & Diamonds

Location: 210 Post Street, San Francisco, CA 94108 

Customer Rating: 5/5

Shop For: Classic rings with sparkling bang-for-buck diamonds.

If you’re shopping for a sparkling diamond ring in a classic style, look no further than RTL Jewelry. For over 20 years, the team at RTL has been sourcing diamonds from all around the world at the best quality and price. While the website leaves a lot to be desired, don’t let this discourage you from checking out their services and quality ring settings.

RTL’s international contacts, experience, design and manufacturing services allow them to buy direct from the source, which results in highly competitive prices for the consumer. Their collection includes a wide range of timeless engagement ring designs. But if you haven’t spotted the perfect ring in their collection, you can use their diamonds to create a custom design to suit your unique style. 

Shop No. 3

Location: 2354 Polk Street in San Francisco, CA 94109

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Shop For: Uber stylish international pieces with modern twists on classic designs

The collection of engagement rings at No. 3 is carefully curated by owner Jenny Chung to cater to modern-meets-timeless tastes. The pieces look classic at first glance. You’ll find recognizable halo, solitaire, and three-stone designs, but upon closer inspection, you’ll find something unique about each one. Whether it is an angular-cut gem, salt and pepper diamond, or art deco design, there is always a standout feature that sets each piece apart.

Edgy meets feminine designs are No. 3’s specialty, and they source collections that fit the bill from all around the world – including Anna Sheffield in New York and Meadolark in New Zealand. You’ll find something in No. 3 to suit every style. And if you don’t, Jenny and her team can create a one-of-a-kind engagement ring for you.

Derco Fine Jewelers

Location: 888 Brannan St #137, San Francisco, CA 94103

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Shop For: Timeless designs crafted by experts in the Bay Area

Derco Fine Jewelers has established themselves as fine jewelry experts in San Francisco since their establishment in the 1970s. Derco is staffed by experts in gemology, metalwork and jewelry making which results in high-quality engagement rings. Some of their experts have been working with Derco for over 30 years, and their dedication to their craft is evident in the exquisite jewelry they produce for delighted clientele.

The website features a range of their designs, including engagement and wedding rings as well as loose diamonds. They also offer a range of jewelry-related services at their store. With close to a thousand 5-star reviews on independent review sites, it’s clear that Derco has a wide base of satisfied customers. 

Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry

Location: 309 Sutter St, San Francisco, CA 94108

Customer Rating: 4.7/5 

Shop For: Authentic vintage engagement rings

Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry has been a landmark in San Francisco’s Union Square shopping district since its establishment in 1969. Their collection boasts a wealth of authentic antique and vintage jewelry – including beautiful engagement rings.

Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry specializes in authentic period rings, original Edwardian and Art Deco era pieces. Stepping inside the store is like stepping back in time with their staff of gemologists, appraisers and vintage jewelry experts as your guide.

If you are looking for an engagement ring that has a little bit of history, you’ll find it at Lang Antique and Estate Jewelry.

Rebecca Overmann

Location: 518 Octavia St. (at Hayes), San Francisco, CA 94102

Customer Rating: 5/5   

Shop For: Understated, fine designs made locally

Rebecca Overmann brings a fresh take on classic designs to the San Francisco jewelry scene. The designer creates her understated pieces in her Mission studio, which shoppers can browse in her Hayes Valley Showroom.

Her signature line of engagement rings is refined yet imbued with femininity. Think simple shapes, understated soft golden tones and gorgeous diamonds. As a trained metalsmith, Rebecca allows the materials to speak for themselves without any overly ornate designs. Her use of old-world techniques creates a unique look, but for something completely personalized, couples can work with Rebecca on a bespoke engagement ring.

You can browse loose stones on her website to get an idea of what gem your ring can feature or make an appointment with Rebecca to discuss your design options. If you are looking for an engagement ring that is equal parts classic, abstract and made in San Francisco then you’ll find it at Rebecca Overmann.

Jewelry Guide