7 Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings in San Francisco

San Francisco is one of the most quintessential American cities. It’s brimming with coastal beauty, urban architecture, and energy. The city is steeped in history while simultaneously shaping the future. It’s this patchwork of old and new, nature and civilization that inspires countless jewelry designers and curators to bring the Bay Area a dazzling collection of engagement rings to suit any style.

This is why picking the best from this large number of engagement ring stores is quite tricky. For this list, we looked at each jeweler’s unique selling points, range and quality of products, customer reviews and the customer service they offer. 

Ready to dive in? Here’s our list of the 8 best places to buy engagement rings in San Francisco.

1. Shreve & Co.

shreve and co. gemstone and diamond engagement-rings

Location: 150 Post St, San Francisco, CA 94108

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Website: Check Shreve & Co. here.

What They Offer:

  • Fine jewelry from around the world in a historic
  • High-end, flagship store
  • One-year limited warranty
  • 30 days exchange/refund policy

Shop For: Fine jewelry from around the world in a historic, high-end, flagship store

Shreve & Co. has called San Francisco home since the 1850s when the company established itself as the finest silver and goldsmith in America during the gold rush era. Shreve’s pieces were sought after by tycoons, establishment families, and politicians with some historic pieces featuring in museums and private collections worldwide.

Shreve & Co. Continue to serve those looking for the finest jewelry, including stunning custom engagement rings made in-house by their experienced team. The collection also includes rings by renowned designers such as Fire and Ice Diamonds, Mikimoto Pearls and Furrer Jacot.

The flagship store is located between the Union Square shopping district and the financial district and is an experience in itself. The luxe interior is a marvel. Couple that with fine jewelry from around the world, and knowledgeable staff and you have yourself a prestigious local classic.

Customer Reviews:

I had a significant amount of correspondence with them through the process and they were very professional & helpful throughout. My fiancée loved the end result and we were happy with quality & price. The care we’ve received post purchasing the ring has also been very to a high standard.

“My partner and I were looking to build a custom engagement ring, and had several disappointing outcomes at other jewelers. At Shreve we were fortunate to work with Thor, who was phenomenal. He really listened to us and asked questions to better understand our vision, and consequently we were thrilled with the outcome. Moreover, our purchase was comparatively small for Palo Alto clients, but we were treated like truly valued customers. For any jewelry purchase we would not hesitate to return.”

2. La Bijouterie

la bijouterie diamond engagement rings

Location: Suite #100, 388 Market St, San Francisco, CA 94111

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Website: Check La Bijouterie here.

What They Offer:

  • Ethically sourced, custom-designed engagement rings
  • Competitive financing options
  • Highly stylish and modern website
  • Live chat service

La Bijouterie is a family-owned high-end jewelry store that prides itself on high-quality designs that use ethical diamonds and gemstones. For three generations, La Bijouterie has been designing made-to-order jewelry that captures each person’s unique style and taste. This is the place to go to if you’re after a reasonably priced custom design engagement ring.

The process is extensive and involves the wearer at almost every step – from initial ideas, sketches, and 3D modeling. The result is a completely unique ring that’s truly personal. La Bijouterie are known for their exceptional customer service, ensuring that you’re satisfied with the end result. They stand behind their products, spending time with each client on even the smallest details.

Customer Reviews:

“Set and his team were great to work with!  I appreciated the small family business feel and the laid back environment they create for their customers.  Purchasing an engagement ring can be a stressful process but Set’s calm demeanor and knowledge made me feel confident that I was making the right choice for my fiancée.  Would highly recommend La Bijouterie!”

“Set @ Bijouterie was very helpful in helping us choose first an engagement ring for complete newbies like us, then also helping us with choosing a wedding band after the engagement went very well! We thought we would have to pay but he walked us through all the rings in our price range and we came out with one that was both stunning but also didn’t break the bank. Thanks Set!”

3. RTL Fine Jewelry & Diamonds

rtl fine jewelry diamonds engagement rings

Location: 210 Post Street, San Francisco, CA 94108 

Customer Rating: 5/5

Website: Check RTL Fine Jewelry & Diamonds here.

What They Offer:

  • GIA & AGS certified diamonds
  • Custom-designed engagement rings
  • One-year limited warranty
  • 30 days exchange/refund policy

If you’re shopping for a sparkling diamond ring in a classic style, look no further than RTL Jewelry. For over 20 years, the team at RTL has been sourcing diamonds from all around the world at the best quality and price. While the website leaves a lot to be desired, don’t let this discourage you from checking out their services and quality ring settings.

RTL’s international contacts, experience, design, and manufacturing services allow them to buy direct from the source, which results in highly competitive prices for the consumer. Their collection includes a wide range of timeless engagement ring designs. But if you haven’t spotted the perfect ring in their collection, you can use their diamonds to create a custom design to suit your unique style. 

Customer Reviews:

“Absolutely loved the ring my fiance got for me – so unique and beautiful – and the sizing was painless.  Everyone compliments me on my ring. I will be using RTL for any future diamond purchases!”

“I recently bought a diamond engagement ring from Rich and could not be happier with my purchase! Rich was there any time I had a question or concern and was prompt in his responses. Despite being located on opposite coasts, there was never a point where I felt a local jeweler would have been preferable.  That is a testament to Rich’s attention and responsiveness. I will absolutely use RTL for any future jewelry needs.”

4. Shop No. 3

shop no. 3 gemstone engagement rings

Location: 2354 Polk Street in San Francisco, CA 94109

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Website: Check Shop No. 3 here.

What They Offer:

  • Stylish engagements ring designs
  • 14 days return/exchange policy
  • Live chat service
  • International shipping

Shop For: Uber stylish international pieces with modern twists on classic designs

The collection of engagement rings at No. 3 is carefully curated by owner Jenny Chung to cater to modern-meets-timeless tastes. The pieces look classic at first glance. You’ll find recognizable halo, solitaire, and three-stone designs, but upon closer inspection, you’ll find something unique about each one. Whether it is an angular-cut gem, salt and pepper diamond, or art deco design, there is always a standout feature that sets each piece apart.

Edgy meets feminine designs are No. 3’s specialty, and they source collections that fit the bill from all around the world – including Anna Sheffield in New York and Meadowlark in New Zealand. You’ll find something in No. 3 to suit every style. And if you don’t, Jenny and her team can create a one-of-a-kind engagement ring for you.

Customer Reviews:

“My partner and I bought my engagement ring here and it was such a wonderful experience! The designs are beautiful and unique, and the staff really goes above and beyond to make it a special experience. Thank you Marcus & the rest of the team for your help, so glad we went with No.3!!”

“We had an amazing experience with the No 3 team in designing my custom engagement ring. My fiancé and I had worked with Marcus on the initial research, and after a couple sessions, my fiancé took things from there working with Marcus and team to design my dream engagement ring. The No 3 team are some of the most genuine, thoughtful, and helpful folks around, and we’re looking forward to continuing to work with them for future pieces!”

5. Derco Fine Jewelers

derco fine jewelers diamond engagement rings

Location: 888 Brannan St #137, San Francisco, CA 94103

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Website: Check Derco Fine Jewelers here.

What They Offer:

  • Conflict-free diamonds
  • Lifetime maintenance
  • 30-day exchange policy
  • Free insured shipping on all US online orders
  • One year warranty

Derco Fine Jewelers has established themselves as fine jewelry experts in San Francisco since their establishment in the 1970s. Derco is staffed by experts in gemology, metalwork and jewelry making which results in high-quality engagement rings. Some of their experts have been working with Derco for over 30 years, and their dedication to their craft is evident in the exquisite jewelry they produce for delighted clientele.

The website features a range of their designs, including engagement and wedding rings as well as loose diamonds. They also offer a range of jewelry-related services at their store. With close to a thousand 5-star reviews on independent review sites, it’s clear that Derco has a wide base of satisfied customers. 

Customer Reviews:

“Highly recommend! My fiancée had a custom setting in mind, which Derco had no problem recreating. The setting is exactly like the pictures my fiancée provided. Everyone there went above and beyond to make sure my fiancée got the ring of her dreams. Special thanks to Katherine for making sure everything was completed on schedule!”

“Highly recommended this place! We got my engagement and wedding ring here and it is perfect! Kathleen was patient and very helpful she showed us alot of choices to pick on and we found the ONE! THANK YOU for your amazing customer service. While I was waiting they offered to clean my ring too and it was a complimentary which is amazing! 5 stars! Go here if you need any jewelry and they will help you out!”

6. Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry

lang antique estate jewelry engagement rings

Location: 309 Sutter St, San Francisco, CA 94108

Customer Rating: 4.7/5 

Website: Check Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry here.

What They Offer:

  • Vintage and antique engagement rings
  • Flexible financing
  • 10 days full refund of purchase price
  • 30 days exchange/store credit policy
  • Free domestic shipping on all orders under $10,000

Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry has been a landmark in San Francisco’s Union Square shopping district since its establishment in 1969. Their collection boasts a wealth of authentic antique and vintage jewelry – including beautiful engagement rings.

Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry specializes in authentic period rings, and original Edwardian and Art Deco era pieces. Stepping inside the store is like stepping back in time with their staff of gemologists, appraisers and vintage jewellery experts as your guide.

If you are looking for an engagement ring that has a little bit of history, you’ll find it at Lang Antique and Estate Jewelry.

Customer Reviews:

“Absolutely stunning & unique engagement rings! We looked at 5+ different jewelry stores, but nobody can match Lang’s quality & selection. Kaye was also incredibly helpful & patient, highly recommend!”

“A great big shout out and thank you to Tracey at Lang. She handled all aspects of our remote transaction flawlessly. She was extremely patient during our decision process. She sent several videos that perfectly depicted my new Tiffany double halo cushion cut sparkler with coordinating wedding band. I am beyond thrilled and will cherish it forever.”

7. Rebecca Overmann

rebecca overmann gemstone engagement rings

Location: 518 Octavia St. (at Hayes), San Francisco, CA 94102

Customer Rating: 5/5   

Website: Check Rebecca Overmann here.

What They Offer:

  • One-of-One engagement rings
  • Collection of natural and rare stones.
  • 7 days exchange policy
  • Live chat service

Rebecca Overmann brings a fresh take on classic designs to the San Francisco jewelry scene. The designer creates her understated pieces in her Mission studio, which shoppers can browse in her Hayes Valley Showroom.

Her signature line of engagement rings is refined yet imbued with femininity. Think simple shapes, understated soft golden tones and gorgeous diamonds. As a trained metalsmith, Rebecca allows the materials to speak for themselves without any overly ornate designs. Her use of old-world techniques creates a unique look, but for something completely personalized, couples can work with Rebecca on a bespoke engagement ring.

You can browse loose stones on her website to get an idea of what gem your ring can feature or make an appointment with Rebecca to discuss your design options. If you are looking for an engagement ring that is equal parts classic, abstract and made in San Francisco then you’ll find it at Rebecca Overmann.

Customer Reviews:

“Rebecca and her team created the most gorgeous ring I’ve ever seen. She crafted the ring my fiancé and I had dreamed of and was incredibly flexible with resizing and making alterations to the ring throughout the process. She is wonderful to work with and her craftsmanship is unparalleled. We can not recommend her highly enough.”

“Rebecca and Lauren were incredible while guiding me through the engagement ring buying process. They were flexible with scheduling and provided great suggestions as I evaluated diamonds for my (now) fiancée. I chose RO because my fiancée initially had a great experience looking at rings here. I can’t imagine going through the ring buying process without this duo to lean on and partner with.”

Dani Rhys

Dani Rhys has worked as a writer and editor for over 15 years in the jewelry niche. She holds a Masters degree in Linguistics and Education. She has always been interested in expression through fashion and accessories, and her extensive experience in the field has made her a respected voice in jewelry trends and education. As the chief editor of Jewelry Shopping Guide, she not only leads the content strategy but also shares her insights through engaging articles. Her passion for storytelling is reflected in every piece she curates, exploring the intricate relationship between jewelry and personal identity.

Jewelry Guide