11 Best Stores to Buy Engagement Rings in Seattle in 2023

With its blend of contemporary flair and timeless charm, Seattle emerges as a top choice for those looking for the ideal engagement ring. The city’s craftsmanship, commitment to ethical sourcing, and design innovations offer a unique backdrop for your ring-hunting experience.  

Let’s take a look at 11 of the most popular stores to buy engagement rings in Seattle and what makes them the best in the business.  

1. Brilliant Earth  

a woman wearing gold diamond rings

Location: 2651 NE 46th St, Seattle, WA 98105, United States 

Customer Rating:  

Brilliant Earth stands out as a favorite destination in Seattle for engagement rings and jewelry. If you’re looking for a bespoke jewelry experience focused on ethical and sustainably sourced jewelry, this is one to check out.  

Choosing Brilliant Earth means you’ll be paired with a seasoned diamond specialist. They’ll introduce you to their state-of-the-art design approach to craft your ideal ring. Once you give the green light on your design, the creation comes to life right in Seattle. 

Brilliant Earth delivers a blend of superior service and exceptional quality, rivaling the price points of digital-only sellers. From selecting the perfect diamond to tailoring a design that speaks to you, the team is committed to their stellar reputation, ensuring that every client is satisfied.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Brilliant Earth. 

2. Turgeon-Raine 

cushion blue sapphire and diamond halo ring

Location: 1300 5th Ave, Seattle, WA 98101, United States 

Customer Rating: 5 Stars 

Turgeon-Raine Jewelers is a perfect blend of age-old traditions and modern innovations, especially when it comes to engagement rings. Their promise? Every ring captures the essence of their unwavering commitment. 

Starting your ring journey with them is quite straightforward. All you have to do is share your dream design, and their skilled artisans get to work. You will receive a detailed 3D digital preview of your dream ring and within a few weeks, they will bring this vision to life.   

What makes them stand out is their professionalism, knowledge, and top-notch communication. So, if you’re on the hunt for that perfect ring, you’re in good hands with Turgeon-Raine. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Turgeon-Raine Jewelers. 

3. Joseph Fine Jewelry 

montana sapphire and diamond halo engagement ring

Location: 1413 4th Ave, Seattle, WA 98101, United States 

Customer Rating: 5 Stars 

For years, Joseph Jewelry has been a top pick in the LA Jewelry District, blending family values with skilled craftsmanship. From natural to lab diamonds, they have something for every taste and budget. Beyond their beautiful jewelry, it’s their warm service that wins hearts. 

Even if you aren’t in the area, you can check out their fully functional website that showcases their products. Their classic designs are expertly crafted and competitively priced. They’re also easy to access, whether by phone, in person consultation, or messaging. If you’re after the ideal ring, we definitely recommend giving Joseph Jewelry a try.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Joseph Jewelry. 

4. L T Denny Jewelers 

pave marquise cut diamond engagement ring

Location: 515 Occidental Ave S, Seattle, WA 98104, United States 

Customer Rating: 5 Stars 

LT Denny offers an upscale boutique experience. They’re renowned for their broad range of options that don’t disappoint, and their prices are reasonable given the high quality. As one reviewer put it, “The quality you get here for the price is outstanding”. Customers also rave about their service and their no-pressure salesmanship.  

For those wanting something special, they’re more than willing to collaborate and craft custom rings tailored to your preferences. While their website might not win any design awards, they’ve got helpful guides that’ll assist ring-shopping rookies. 

Lt Denny is big on ethically sourced diamonds and back their work with a lifetime warranty for both craftsmanship and any shipping damages. If you change your mind about the ring or it’s not what you imagined, they have a 30-day return policy. They ship for free not just within the US but also to several international destinations like Australia, Europe, and New Zealand. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: L T Denny Jewelers 

5. Green Lake Jewelry 

diamond petal milgrain engagement ring in yellow gold setting

Location: 550 NE Northgate Way, Seattle, WA 98125, United States 

Customer Rating: 4.9 Stars 

True to their artisan spirit, Green Lake Jewelry Works offers a unique and tailored experience when it comes to buying diamonds and jewelry. With years of craftsmanship under their belt, they’ve become experts at what they do. 

One of the main highlights of Green Lake Jewelry Works is their vast engagement ring collection, showcasing not just classic styles but also vibrant gemstones and modern intricate designs. And if you’re dreaming of something truly one-of-a-kind, they excel in custom-made rings. Also check out their Mountain Ring Collection and Matching Wedding Sets – truly delightful and expertly crafted!  

Their website is a testament to their attention to detail. It recently got a refresh, now boasting 360-degree videos and zoomed-in photos, letting you get up close and personal with each piece. This makes your online browsing and shopping journey seamless, rivaling the best diamond retailers out there. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Green Lake Jewelry 

6. Tara Nash Jeweler and Diamond Buyer 

fancy yellow diamond halo engagement ring

Location: 1325 4th Ave #920, Seattle, WA 98101, United States 

Customer Rating: 4.8 Stars 

In 2000, Tara Nash established Tara Nash Jeweler and Diamond Buyer, and today it stands as one of the top local engagement ring boutiques in the city. For those looking for a personalized touch with their jewelry choices, this is your go-to spot. Tara meets with each client and makes the appointment pleasant and stress-free. But you can also have your meeting digitally, so you don’t need to live in the area to avail yourself of Tara’s services.  

Her website showcases an extensive range of engagement, wedding rings, and exquisite diamond jewelry. She offers a wide range of engagement ring styles, from antique to modern. This section is a visual treat, offering videos of actual customer rings, which stand as a testament to her and her team’s craftsmanship. 

We liked that all diamonds sourced by Tara Nash are GIA certified and ethically procured. The satisfaction of their clients is clear from the glowing reviews she’s received. If you’re on the hunt for a truly personalized engagement ring experience, you should definitely give Tara Nash a try.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Tara Nash Jeweler and Diamond Buyer. 

7. Lauren’s Jewelry  

diamond halo engagement ring on the woman's ring

Location: 2600 SW Barton St Suite E4, Seattle, WA 98126, United States 

Customer Rating: 4.7 Stars 

Lauren’s Jewelry is your destination for top quality artistry and individualized attention. Every jewelry piece at Lauren’s Jewelry is made with precision in their local studio. Their diamonds are carefully sourced and are of high quality. And if you’re leaning towards lab-created diamonds, they’ve got those in their repertoire as well. 

What stands out about Lauren’s Jewelry is their dedication to transparent dealings and responsibility. This shines through in the way they treat their customers. To sweeten the deal, every engagement ring purchase includes an independent third-party valuation, lifetime cleaning and sizing at no extra cost, complimentary shipping, and the assurance of conflict-free sourcing! 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Lauren’s Jewelry 

8. Ben Bridge Jeweler 

oval shaped diamond engagement ring in yellow gold setting

Location: 1530 5th Ave, Seattle, WA 98101, United States 

Customer Rating: 4.8 Stars 

It’s not just about the glitz and glamour; it’s about the value and service. Ben Bridge Jeweler is committed to offering top-tier engagement rings without breaking the bank. Thanks to their position in the industry, they can bypass a lot of the usual markups, giving you more sparkle for your money. 

Whether you’re in for a one-of-a-kind creation or something from their exquisite collection, Ben Bridge caters to all. Whether your budget is tight at $1,000 or stretches up to $50,000, they’ll craft or help you pick a ring that’s just right for you. 

Navigating through their website is a breeze. They’ve got a broad array of bridal rings, men’s bands, diamonds, and customizable options. But if you fancy a more hands-on experience, just book a no-pressure, free consultation at their store. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Ben Bridge Jeweler. 

9. Baraka Gems 

round cut four prong diamond engagement ring

Location: 8218 Greenwood Ave N, Seattle, WA 98103, United States 

Customer Rating: 5 Stars 

In Seattle, Baraka Gems has made a name for itself with its beautifully handcrafted jewelry and rings. Their online collection, though curated, vividly displays the level of craftsmanship and elegance they bring to the table. Their custom engagement rings are more than just jewelry; they symbolize their unwavering commitment to distinctive designs and perfect finishes. 

But it’s not only about the jewelry at Baraka Gems. They’re known to go above and beyond with their wide range of customer-focused services. Apart from crafting bespoke pieces, they’re experts in reviving treasured heirloom stones, restoring old rings to their former glory, re-stringing pearls, and conducting detailed jewelry appraisals.  

They’re known for their professionalism, fair pricing, and genuine approach. If you’re looking for an unparalleled experience in Seattle, Baraka Gems should be on your list. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Baraka Gems. 

10. Olympic Jewelers 

antique old european cut diamond engagement ring

Location: 3510 Fremont Pl N, Seattle, WA 98103, United States 

Customer Rating: 4.9 Stars

Olympic Jewelers is a family-run business that’s been offering top-quality service and expertise for many years. They’re famous for their beautifully handcrafted custom rings and have a long history in the craft, ensuring every piece is a masterpiece.  

Partnering with several well-known designers, their collection effortlessly blends timeless classics with modern flair. Whether you’re eyeing a classic solitaire or something more contemporary, you can find it at Olympic Jewelry, both online and at their physical store. 

But there’s more to them than just rings. They come with some great benefits like a program to upgrade your ring, free delivery, a solid lifetime guarantee, and they’ll even clean or shine up your ring for free. If you need some time to pay, they’ve got easy payment plans.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Olympic Jewelers 

11. Aide-mémoire 

oval halo diamond engagement ring on the woman's ring finger

Location: 7003 3rd Ave NW, Seattle, WA 98117, United States 

Customer Rating: 5 Stars 

Aide-mémoire aims to do just that – create pieces of jewelry that will remind you of the beautiful memories associated with it. They handcraft heirloom quality rings for all special occasions. They team up with some of the best designers, ensuring their collections are unique and exclusive, and are a beautiful mix of timeless pieces and the latest designs. Whether you’re after a modern minimalist design or a vintage-inspired solitaire, you’ll find it here.  

Their store also offers impressive perks like an upgrade program, zero-cost shipping and a rock-solid lifetime guarantee. They promise to keep your ring looking as good as new with their complimentary cleaning and polishing service and also have flexible financing options. And if you’re new to the world of jewelry, their website is a treasure trove of information, loaded with articles and insights. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Aide-mémoire. 

Wrapping Up  

Whether you’re drawn to classic diamonds or unique gemstones, Seattle offers something for every taste and budget. When shopping for your engagement ring, remember to enjoy the process, trust your instincts, and let the Emerald City’s jewelers guide you to the perfect symbol of your love story.

Jewelry Guide