How to Choose Men’s Diamond Rings – A Handy Guide

For a lot of people, what springs to mind when they think of men’s rings is a simple wedding band, often with no decoration, style or flair. But men’s rings can be so much more than just that and that’s where diamond rings come in.

There are many styles of men’s diamond rings available to suit all styles, whether minimalist or maximalist. You could opt for a diamond ring for your wedding ring, a male engagement ring or simply to wear when you feel like it. It’s all about finding the right ring to suit your style and then to wear it with flare! Let’s take a look at what you need to consider before you buy a male diamond ring.

Consider Your Style

channel set diamond with satin finished ring
Stylish and sophisticated. See this here.

To buy the right ring, consider what style you’re aiming for. If you prefer to dress in casual attire and have a casual sense of style, then a flashy diamond ring with multiple flashy stones might not be for you. Instead, you might want to opt for something more minimalist.

Men diamond ring with yellow stone
A diamond ring to wear with flare. See it here.

Or you might be someone who frequently wears suits and formal attire. in this case, you probably want a ring that comes across as classy and sophisticated rather than loud and eye-catching.

If you like loud bling and eye-catching, sparkly jewelry, you might find yourself gravitating towards hip hop jewelry and styles. Knowing what style you prefer will help you to narrow down your search for your diamond ring.

Consider Your Lifestyle

Just as the style is important, so is the lifestyle. The fact of the matter is that while diamond rings are beautiful and stylish, they can also be less durable than we might want them to be.

If you tend to use your hands a lot at work or are very active durability should be your chief priority. You’ll be looking at a metal that can withstand wear and tear and a design that is less likely to get damaged. For example, a platinum ring like this one with a channel set row of diamonds will offer more in terms of durability than an elaborate ring like this one.

The Occasion

diagonal swirl with pave diamond ring
The right ring can fit into any occasion. See this here.

The answer is of course – whenever you feel like! While women typically gravitate towards jewelry more than men, these days an increasing number of men are wearing jewelry to express themselves. This means that there’s no specific requirement on when and where you should wear a diamond ring. From the work place to a party, a diamond ring can seamless blend in to any occasion.

Pick a Budget

white tungsten carbide diamond band
An alternative metal makes for affordable rings. See this here.

As with anything else, setting a specific budget before going into the market is always wise. The prices for men’s diamond rings can vary from a couple of hundred dollars to multiple thousands, depending on the style and design of the ring, on metal used, on the size and type of the gemstone as well as on manufacturer’s brand.

And while we definitely don’t recommend settling for a lower quality manufacturer or materials, as this usually means a much shorter life for the ring, there are still multiple budget decision to be made when it comes to the design, the type of metal and the stone.

Just make sure that you don’t get so wrapped up in budget concerns that you get ripped off with a cheap cubic zirconia ring masquerading as a diamond ring. Remember, if it’s too good to be true, it probably is.

Choose Your Metal

rose gold men diamond wedding band
A beautiful rose gold diamond ring. See it here.

While there are many metals out there, not all are created equal. Some ring metals might be more popular than others but don’t get influenced by that – consider which metal would be ideal for your particular style, needs and situation. Here’s a quick breakdown of the main types of metals used in diamond rings:

1. Platinum

Among the most popular metal choices, platinum is rare, prestigious, and stylish, as well as very hard and durable. It also happens to be one of the most expensive choices, so be prepared to fork over your cash.

2. 14K and 18K Gold

Gold comes in three main colors and two main levels of gold purity. Gold is a classic choice and will always hold value.

  • 14K and 18K Yellow Gold: The traditional wedding ring choice, yellow gold has a beautiful and classic look. Yellow gold with diamonds provides a beautiful contrast and makes for a classic, vintage look.
  • 14K and 18K White Gold: An alloy of gold and other metals such as palladium and silver, white gold also typically has a rhodium plating. These rings are beautiful and classy but require maintenance as the rhodium wears off over time.
  • 14K and 18K Rose Gold: Similar to yellow gold but with more a romantic tone, rose gold is a popular choice for wedding rings and bands. It also makes for very sophisticated fashion diamond rings for men.

3. Alternative Metals

These days, there are so many metal options for men’s rings that it’s not even funny! From tungsten carbide to titanium, tantalum to rhodium coated silver, these options are affordable but that doesn’t mean you’re compromising on looks and quality.

Choose Your Diamond Size

For men’s diamond rings, it’s more common to have diamond melees as opposed to a single large stone. The description of the ring should tell you the total carat weight of the piece. Take a look at the screenshot below. The total weight of all the diamonds in this ring is 1 carat.

diamond carat weight wtih ring
A series of channel set diamonds. See this ring here.

If you were to buy a single 1 carat diamond, you’d be spending about $10,000. Smaller diamonds of the same weight as a larger diamond are always less expensive, all else being equal. Instead of asking what size diamond you need, just go with the aesthetics of the ring. Choose one that appeals to you, whether it holds a single embedded diamond or is ‘iced out’ with dozens of tiny melees.

Types of Men’s Diamond Rings

single stone diamond ring
A single stone diamond ring. See it here.

1. A Solitary Stone Diamond Ring

A single stone ring is classy and understated. It still maintains the traditional ring look while venturing forth slightly into the world of sparkling diamonds. This is a great choice if you want a ring that is not too eye-catching or out of the ordinary… something that’ll blend right in.

2. A Channel Set Diamond Ring

This type of men’s diamond rings adds more sparkle and has a chic and modern look. It utilizes several small melee diamonds running around a part of or the entire circumference of the ring. The pattern can vary depending on the design. You can choose either colorless or black diamonds, depending on the look you want.

3. A Statement Diamond Ring

Large men diamond ring
A dazzling diamond ring with 14.24 carats. See it here.

This type of rings grabs your attention. They come in a variety of designs, and the carat weight can range from as little as .30 to over  15 carats, made up of numerous sparkling melees.

Frost NYC has one of the best collections of dazzling diamond rings that you can’t take your eyes away from. Browse it here

How Much Do Men’s Diamond Rings Cost?

As we touched above, men’s diamond rings can vary greatly in cost – from just several hundred dollars to several thousand dollars. What’s great about this is that it gives you a huge variety to choose from. There are many great and affordable diamond rings if you just want something simple with small stones that is still of high-quality design and materials. And if you want something very affordable, then opt for either lab-created diamonds or diamond look alike.

Which Finger Should You Wear Your Diamond Ring On?

Men diamond engagement ring

A cool thing about men’s diamond rings is that there are no rules on how or where you should wear them.

  • Thumb rings: Thumb rings aren’t that common but they are actually growing in popularity. The main benefit of thumb rings is that they don’t overcrowd the rest of your fingers, making them great for people who work a lot with their hands.
  • Index Finger Rings: These rings are meant to be seen. As the index finger is the one we use to point at things and wave around most of the time, if you want people to notice your flashy ring, this is where you should put it.
  • Middle Finger Rings: There are no traditions or social restrictions and rules when it comes to middle finger rings. Just keep in mind that this is your largest finger and putting a bulky ring on it can be uncomfortable.
  • Ring Finger Rings: This is the traditional choice for most rings, particularly wedding rings or bands on the left hand. Wearing a ring on this finger will usually give the impression that you’re married. If this isn’t something you want to have to deal with, avoid the ring finger.
  • Small Finger Rings: Wearing a men’s diamond ring for pinky fingers does have its historical significance. Traditionally, this finger has been used for signet rings used to sign legal documents. It’s a great finger to wear a ring on as it is comfortable and even has a professional appearance.

Where to Buy Men’s Diamond Rings

As with all types of jewelry, men’s diamond rings should only be purchased from trusted and reputable vendors to avoid being ripped off with lower quality or an overpriced product. There are lots of vendors to choose from. However, if you are new to this niche and you want to make sure that you won’t go to the wrong place, here are our suggestions:

1. Blue Nile

If you’re looking for an affordable men’s diamond ring of good quality, Blue Nile pride themselves on offering great prices for great products. Their website is an excellent first stop for everyone who’s just getting into diamond hunting and doesn’t want to fall prey to unnecessarily overpriced vendors or cheap fakes. What’s more, Blue Nile’s customer service is also top-notch which is great for assisting people new to the area.

2. James Allen

For those looking for fine jewelry, James Allen is a great place to visit. All their products are of the highest quality and they do have a vast selection of rings – from the most impressive and expensive pieces, to quite a few affordable ones. Their site offers a great experience for online shopping thanks to the 360-degree HD videos of all their rings and the 24/7 specialized customer service. With over 10 years of experience in online shopping, James Allen is a great choice.

3. Frost NYC

Frost NYC is known as one of the best jewelry companies in the US and especially on the East Coast. They offer fast shipping, a smooth transaction, and a great price/quality ratio. They also have a great assortment of men’s diamond rings, as well as other jewelry options, plus their attentive customer service staff is always available to help you navigate their site.

4. Hip Hop Bling

If you’re looking for more than just a ring band with a small diamond but want a men’s diamond ring that will grab the attention of everyone around you, Hip Hop Bling is the place to look for it. The vast majority of their men’s rings and other jewelry is covered with diamonds or simulants and other stones in an extravagant manner. What’s more, all this is offered for quite affordable prices.

5. Etsy

If you are looking for a handmade artisan men’s diamond ring, Etsy is probably the one place you shouldn’t skip. You can find multiple independent jewelry boutiques on Etsy, each with their own assortment of rings. Each Etsy shop has its own polices so it might take some time to review all their details ahead of making a purchase, but that’s usually time well-spent. Buying a man’s diamond ring from the right Etsy shop can get you a truly unique and special ring to cherish for years.

Wrapping Up

Finding the perfect diamond ring isn’t all that hard, with all the options available for men today. It was a different story five years ago, but today, all the major retailers offer classy and stylish designs.

Dani Rhys

Dani Rhys has worked as a writer and editor for over 15 years in the jewelry niche. She holds a Masters degree in Linguistics and Education. She has always been interested in expression through fashion and accessories, and her extensive experience in the field has made her a respected voice in jewelry trends and education. As the chief editor of Jewelry Shopping Guide, she not only leads the content strategy but also shares her insights through engaging articles. Her passion for storytelling is reflected in every piece she curates, exploring the intricate relationship between jewelry and personal identity.

Jewelry Guide