11 Best Stores to Buy Engagement Rings in Philadelphia

When it comes to buying engagement rings in the city of Philadelphia, the options are as rich and varied as its storied past. From quaint, historic lanes housing vintage treasures to contemporary boutiques showcasing modern designs, Philly ensures every love-struck soul finds their perfect ring.  

Here are twelve of the most popular stores in Philadelphia for engagement rings and why they’re the best. 

1. L. Priori Jewelry 

sapphire and diamond engagement ring on the woman's finger

Location: 1719 Chestnut St #300, Philadelphia, PA 19103, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars 

L. Priori Jewelry in Philadelphia is rapidly gaining a reputation as the go-to spot for diamond enthusiasts who want both quality and value. One thing we absolutely adore about them is how passionate they are about creating that perfect engagement ring for you. And trust us, they’re swift; many of their custom designs are ready in a mere few weeks.  

When you browse their website, you’ll be spoilt for choice with their pre-made designs, all handcrafted with precision in their local workshop. Whether you’re dreaming of a unique masterpiece or fancy something from their stylish ready-to-wear collection, they have your back. 

You can check out their website or stroll into their Philly store, making your shopping experience versatile. We’ve also noticed their prices tend to be friendlier than some Philly competitors. This might be because they smartly bypass intermediaries when getting their diamonds. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: L. Priori Jewelry. 

2. Steven Singer Jewelers 

princess cut diamond engagement ring on the woman's finger

Location: 739 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19106, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.7 Stars 

Ever since opening their doors in 1974, Steven Singer Jewelers in Philadelphia has held a heartfelt commitment to their customers. Their genuine care made us feel special and appreciated from the moment we stepped into the store.  

We were impressed by their wide selection of engagement rings, ranging from classic designs to contemporary wedding bands. And it doesn’t end with just browsing; Steven Singer takes pride in crafting custom designs tailored just for you. Their impeccable repair, cleaning, and restoration services will help you to keep your jewelry in top condition. 

For those in search of a personal touch, a vast collection, and a jeweler who truly values their customers, Steven Singer Jewelers shines bright in the heart of Philadelphia. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Steven Singer Jewelers. 

3. Barski Diamonds 

art deco inspired sapphire diamond engagement ring

Location: 724 Sansom St, Philadelphia, PA 19106, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

Barski Diamonds in Philadelphia is a family-run business known for its high-quality jewelry. They’ve been experts in diamond cutting and jewelry design for many years, and this shows in their work, especially their engagement rings. 

What we liked the most about Barski Diamonds is that they treat everyone like family, and shoppers don’t feel pushed to buy. The company offers more than just jewelry sales. They also provide services like engraving, resizing rings, appraisals, and cleaning. 

Given their reputation and quality, it’s no surprise that Barski Diamonds is a top choice in Philadelphia for jewelry. If you want good craftsmanship and a straightforward shopping experience, consider visiting their store or checking out their website. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Barski Diamonds. 

4. Sydney Rosen Company 

halo diamond engagement rings in white gold setting

Location: 714 Sansom St, Philadelphia, PA 19106, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

Sydney Rosen Company has been in the jewelry business for over 50 years, becoming a trusted name for many. They’re known for their excellent craftsmanship and good customer service. Their handcrafted engagement rings reflect their belief in enduring love. 

Their collection includes a wide range of engagement rings, from classic to modern designs. They also offer custom-made rings for those who want something unique. Every piece from Sydney Rosen is certified, ensuring quality. 

In addition to selling jewelry, they also guide buyers, especially those unfamiliar with jewelry. Their website and store staff were very helpful when it came to choosing the right piece. They also provide extra services like free appraisals, a return policy, free shipping, regular maintenance, and resizing. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Sydney Rosen Company. 

5. Unclaimed Diamonds  

round and baguettes diamond engagement ring

Location: 113 S 8th St, Philadelphia, PA 19106, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

Unclaimed Diamonds in Philadelphia has a long-standing tradition of creating quality jewelry. Their online collection, though not vast, highlights their attention to detail and craftsmanship. Their custom rings aren’t just purchases, but unique pieces of art. 

In addition to their jewelry, Unclaimed Diamonds offers various services like re-setting heirloom stones, repairing rings, re-stringing pearls, and providing jewelry appraisals. We appreciated their professionalism, pricing, and friendly staff. Whether online or in-store, visiting Unclaimed Diamonds is a worthwhile experience. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Unclaimed Diamonds. 

6. Golden Nugget Jewelers 

vintage inspired milgrain diamond engagement ring

Location: 800 Chestnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19107, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.7 Stars 

Golden Nugget Jewelers is a family-run business in Philadelphia since 1987, popular for its trusted advice on engagement rings. They specialize in custom designs, partnering with top designers like Tacori, Verragio, Simon G, and Gabriel. Their collection ranges from classic solitaires to modern halo settings, available in-store and online. 

They offer added value with benefits such as a trade-up program, free shipping, a lifetime warranty, and regular cleaning services. They have flexible financing options and a 14-day return policy, showing confidence in their products. We found their website to be extremely helpful as it contains a lot of educational content and blogs for customers. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Golden Nugget Jewelers. 

7. William Schwartz Distinctive Jewelry 

pear shaped diamond engagement ring on the ring finger

Location: 1831 Chestnut St # A, Philadelphia, PA 19103, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

William Schwartz Distinctive Jewelry is known for its sustainable and traditional approach. They offer a range of jewelry suitable for everyday wear and special events. Their focus on using 100% recycled materials and vintage diamonds for engagement rings makes them a top choice for eco-conscious buyers in the city. 

Their website provides a snapshot of their handcrafted designs. All items are custom-made based on individual preferences, which means they don’t offer standard returns, a common practice with bespoke pieces.  

We loved that each purchase comes with a handmade wooden jewelry box, adding a personal touch. This dedication makes William Schwartz more than just a jeweler; they offer a meaningful shopping experience for special occasions. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: William Schwartz Distinctive Jewelry. 

8. House of Milner Jewelers 

split shank diamond engagement ring in white gold setting

Location: The JE Caldwell Building, 728 Sansom St, Philadelphia, PA 19106, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars 

House of Milner Jewelers began as “Milner Gem House” in 1925. Founded by John Milner, the shop prioritized customer trust. In the 1960s, Thomas Milner took over, and by the 1980s, his children led the store, evolving it into the renowned House of Milner Jewelers. Their focus remains on customer satisfaction and a wide selection of engagement rings. 

The jeweler features designs from names like Laurent, Aria L, Gabriel Stone, and Leo Mystique, catering to those wanting designer rings. We were pleasantly surprised to find that they have an eco-friendly lab diamond collection that combines quality with good pricing. 

House of Milner offers notable services, including a lifetime warranty, a diamond trade-up option, regular cleaning, and inspection, and easy financing. They provide a 30-day return policy, though custom rings have different conditions. For quality jewelry with a trusted history, House of Milner Jewelers is a top choice. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: House of Milner Jewelers. 

9. Emily Chelsea Jewelry 

Location: 2429 E Gordon St, Philadelphia, PA 19125, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars 

Emily Chelsea Jewelry in Philadelphia is famous for good prices and top-quality diamonds. They focus on creating custom engagement rings that match the buyer’s style and they design and make these special rings in roughly 2.5 weeks. Alongside custom pieces, Emily Chelsea’s Philadelphia shop offers many ready-to-buy rings, showcasing her attention to detail. 

Customers can choose their rings either by visiting her shop or online. The prices are often lower than expected, as they avoid unnecessary costs by not involving middlemen. What makes Emily Chelsea stand out is her team’s helpful and quick service. Buying an engagement ring from her is more than a purchase; it’s a memorable experience. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Emily Chelsea Jewelry. 

10. Bario Neal Jewelry 

radiant cut diamond engagement ring on the ring finger

Location: 524 S 5th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

Bario Neal Jewelry has a rich history of valuing its customers. Established in 2009, their approach is rooted in appreciation and welcoming every visitor warmly. Their collection is diverse, catering to various budgets and tastes in diamonds and rings. 

They’ve collaborated with the renowned designer, Delia Langan, and together they offer an impressive array of designs online, from timeless engagement rings to unique wedding bands. Apart from their ready-to-wear collection, Bario Neal excels in creating custom jewelry, ensuring each piece aligns with a client’s personal vision. They also offer reliable jewelry services like repair, maintenance, and restoration, guaranteeing longevity for your valued items. 

For those in Philadelphia searching for a blend of variety, craftsmanship, and top-tier service, we recommend Bario Neal Jewelry as a great place to start. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Bario Neal Jewelry. 

11. Safian & Rudolph Jewelers 

round and baguette cut side diamond engagement ring with oval cut diamond center stone

Location: 701 Sansom St, Philadelphia, PA 19106, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.6 Stars 

Known for their expertise in diamonds and custom jewelry, Safian & Rudolph Jewelers offers a wide range of engagement rings, from classic to modern styles. Customers appreciate the detailed designs and varied settings they offer. 

Customers often praise the friendly and helpful service they receive, noting the lack of sales pressure that’s common in most other jewelry stores. Howard and his team ensure each client feels valued. 

In addition to their jewelry, Safian & Rudolph provides services like engraving, resizing, upgrades, and jewelry care. Their strong reputation in Philadelphia makes them a top choice for jewelry needs. They have both a physical store and an online platform for customers to explore. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Safian & Rudolph Jewelers. 

Wrapping Up  

Buying an engagement ring in Philadelphia offers a unique blend of history, craftsmanship, and personal touch. Whether you’re drawn to vintage allure or modern simplicity, Philadelphia’s jewelers understand the gravity of the moment and craft rings that tell stories. In Philadelphia, finding the perfect symbol of your commitment becomes an intimate and memorable journey.

Jewelry Guide