11 Best Stores to Buy Engagement Rings in New Jersey

Selecting the ideal engagement ring in New Jersey isn’t just about the jewelry; it’s a chapter in your romantic tale. The state is home to numerous jewelers, renowned for their skill and genuine pieces. 

Here are twelve standout stores in Hawaii for engagement rings and the reasons they’re top-notch. 

1. The Jewelry Exchange (Hackensack) 

round and marquise diamond engagement ring

Location: 171 Main St, Hackensack, NJ 07601, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

The Jewelry Exchange, based in New Jersey, is quickly becoming a favorite spot for diamond enthusiasts. Renowned for their affordable prices and exquisite engagement rings, this establishment is gaining a stronghold in the diamond market. 

What stands out about The Jewelry Exchange is their knack for crafting customized engagement rings tailored to individual tastes. Their lead times are impressive, with the majority of their custom-made rings being ready in as little as 2.5 weeks. We particularly liked their in-house collection of ready-made rings, which offers a plethora of choices for those who need a ring immediately.   

After doing a quick price check against several Los Angeles-based retailers, we found that The Jewelry Exchange tends to be more wallet-friendly. This price advantage stems from their direct-to-consumer approach, minimizing middleman costs. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: The Jewelry Exchange. 

2. Spivak Jewelers and Engagement Rings (Cherry Hill) 

round diamond pave engagement ring

Location: 1871 Marlton Pike East suite 9, Cherry Hill, NJ 08003, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

Nestled in the heart of New Jersey, you’ll find Spivak Jewelers and Engagement Rings, a name closely linked with putting customers first. Founded with a mission to honor and celebrate love and commitment, Spivak’s main goal is to ensure that every person who walks into their store feels valued and truly understood. Their collection is carefully designed to fit a wide range of budgets, making sure to cater to everyone. 

Teaming up with famous designers like Gabriel and Co., Spivak Jewelers expands its selection to include both brands. This collaboration provides a wide range of choices for engagement and wedding ring designs.  

However, Spivak goes beyond just selling. They excel in crafting unique pieces and provide exceptional services for fixing, cleaning, and restoring jewelry. If you live in New Jersey and are looking for a combination of options, personalization, and unmatched service, Spivak Jewelers and Engagement Rings is a great choice.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Spivak Jewelers. 

3. Diamond Hut Jewelers (Jersey City) 

sapphire and diamond three stone engagement ring

Location: 701 NJ-440, Jersey City, NJ 07304, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

Based in Jersey City, Diamond Hut Jewelers has spent many years perfecting their craft with commitment and passion. Their engagement ring collections reflect this dedication, with each ring showing their careful work. The rings come in many designs, from classic looks to modern ones, with all sorts of different settings. 

We were impressed by the customer service at Diamond Hut Jewelers. The team, led by a passionate leader, makes sure that every customer feels important and heard, without using any high-pressure sales tactics.  

They offer many services, like adding engravings, resizing rings, giving appraisals, and more. If you live on the East Coast, you should definitely consider checking out Diamond Hut Jewelers, either by going in person or using their easy online site. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Diamond Hut Jewelers. 

4. Brilliant Diamonds (Wayne) 

diamond halo engagement rings on fingers

Location: 57 NJ-23, Wayne, NJ 07470, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars 

Over the years, Brilliant Diamonds has become known for their exceptional skill and top-notch customer service. When we explored their collection, we discovered a variety of beautifully pre-designed engagement rings in classic settings and styles.  

For those who want something special, their personalized services offer the opportunity to turn your ideas into tangible symbols of affection. Every item from Brilliant Diamonds comes with certifications from leading institutions like GIA and AGS.  

They’re committed to educating customers, helping them to can make well-informed choices when purchasing an engagement ring. They also offer a wide range of services, including assessments, free resizing, and preventative maintenance.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Brilliant Diamonds. 

5. W. Kodak Jewelers (Hoboken) 

diamond solitaire engagement rings on fingers

Location: 60 Newark St., Hoboken, NJ 07030, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

W. Kodak Jewelers, a renowned name in Hoboken, is a popular choice for couples looking for the perfect engagement ring. Their e-commerce platform beautifully showcases their offerings, inviting clients to explore their extensive collection from anywhere. 

Their engagement ring selection is diverse, catering to various preferences and budgets. They have various pieces from timeless classics to contemporary designs. W. Kodak Jewelers also offer hassle-free returns, lifetime warranties, custom jewelry creation, and swift shipping. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: W. Kodak Jewelers. 

6. Raj Jewels (Iselin) 

rose gold diamond halo engagement rings

Location: 1376 Oak Tree Rd, Iselin, NJ 08830, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

Located in the heart of the jewelry district, Raj Jewels has earned its name for crafting exquisite engagement rings by hand. Their online collection might be small, but it’s carefully chosen to show off their impressive artistry and precision. Each engagement ring they create reflects their dedication to uniqueness and sophistication. 

What sets Raj Jewels apart is their range of services focused on customers. They also offer services like resetting precious family stones, careful repairs and polishing for older rings, restringing pearls, and accurate appraisals for jewelry.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Raj Jewels. 

7. Hamilton Jewelers (Princeton) 

rose gold diamond split shank engagement ring

Location: 92 Nassau St, Princeton, NJ 08542, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

Renowned for its elegance and attention to detail, Hamilton Jewelers stands out due to its careful and skillful creation of jewelry. This is especially true when it comes to engagement rings.  

But what truly sets Hamilton Jewelers apart goes beyond their exceptional product quality. They offer services that focus on the customer’s needs. What we especially liked was that they also offer services like resetting heirloom gemstones, repairs, and refinishing.  

Alongside accurate jewelry appraisals, Hamilton ensures a complete and well-rounded jewelry experience. Their professionalism and services shows why they’re a favorite for those looking for the perfect engagement ring.   

To book a consultation, check their website here: Hamilton Jewelers. 

8. Adlers Jewelers (Westfield) 

emerald cut diamond engagement ring

Location: 217 N Ave W, Westfield, NJ 07090, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars 

Adlers Jewelers is a top spot for engagement rings, known for their honesty and high quality products and services. They’re a family-run business that’s been around for years, making more than just rings – they make memorable moments. 

They’re really proud of their unique, hand-made ring designs, crafted by a skilled team. They’ve partnered with big-name designers like Tacori and Gabriel, offering a wide range of beautiful rings. Whether you’re into classic designs or more modern styles, they’ve got you covered. 

We enjoyed the benefits you get with Adlers, like the option to trade up their rings, free delivery, a reliable warranty, and regular ring upkeep. Their return time might be a bit quick, but they make up for it with their detailed website that’s full of useful information to help buyers make the right choice. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Adlers Jewelers. 

9. Family & Co. Jewelers (Marlton) 

pear shape diamond in v shape engagement ring

Location: 65 NJ-70, Marlton, NJ 08053, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars 

Family & Co. Jewelers, as their name suggests, has a rich legacy as a family-operated jewelry store, renowned for their exquisite engagement rings. Deeply rooted in tradition, they’ve consistently offered not just jewelry, but also genuine experiences for generations. They’re experts at making handcrafted rings that show how much they care about their work. 

They have a wide range of rings to choose from, including classic styles and newer, trendy designs. They also work with top designers to give you even more unique options.  

But what makes them stand out is how well they treat their customers. If you’re looking for a special design, need your ring looked after, or just want some advice, they’re there to help. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Family & Co. Jewelers. 

10. Diamond Castle (Manalapan) 

floral halo diamond engagement ring in yellow gold setting

Location: 355 US-9, Manalapan Township, NJ 07726, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

Diamond Castle is a popular store to shop at for engagement rings, located in Manalapan, New Jersey. They have a unique approach, crafting each ring with precision and care, making them stand out in the crowded jewelry market. We found that the Diamond Castle website doesn’t display their entire collection, was quite disappointing. However, what’s showcased is enough to highlight their exceptional craftsmanship and aesthetic appeal. 

Every piece at Diamond Castle is customized to the buyer’s preference, ensuring that no two rings are the same. While this personalized touch means there’s no return or refund, this is a standard practice for tailor-made jewelry in most places. 

A standout feature is their elegant packaging. The engagement ring arrives in a beautifully crafted wooden box, reflecting Diamond Castle’s commitment to details and making them a top choice for those looking for a special ring shopping experience. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Diamond Castle. 

11. Unique Gold & Diamonds (Clifton) 

solitaire diamond engagement rings in yellow and white gols settings

Location: 613 Van Houten Ave, Clifton, NJ 07013, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

Unique Gold & Diamonds is known for its great craftsmanship. Even though it’s not as old as some other jewelry stores, it’s a go-to spot in Clifton for a wide variety of engagement rings, from traditional styles to modern and unique ones. 

Each ring at Unique Gold & Diamonds has its own special story and they have a mix of old-fashioned as well as new designs. We liked that they’re careful about where their materials come from, especially with their lab-grown diamonds that are both good quality and ethically made. 

What really makes Unique Gold & Diamonds special is how much they care about their customers. They focus on quality, doing the right thing, and making their customers happy. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Unique Gold & Diamonds. 

Wrapping Up  

New Jersey offers a rich variety of options for shopping for engagement rings. From high-end boutiques to local jewelers, there’s something for every style and budget. Explore the stores in this list to find the perfect symbol of your love and commitment. 

Jewelry Guide