11 Best Stores to Buy Engagement Rings in Boston

In the quest for the perfect symbol of love and commitment, Boston presents an impressive selection of jewelry boutiques catering to all tastes and styles. These 12 top stores for engagement rings in Boston stand out for their exceptional craftsmanship, client service, and variety tailored to suit every budget. 

1. Brilliant Earth  

a woman wearing a three-stone diamond engagement ring

Location: 38 Newbury St #603, Boston, MA 02116, United States 

Customer Reviews: 3.8 Stars

Starting off in San Francisco and now making a splash in Boston, Brilliant Earth truly shines when it comes to crafting stunning jewelry. The brand combines traditional designs with modern sophistication, earning kudos for its talented craftsmen and impressive designer ties.  

Customer happiness is at the heart of what Brilliant Earth does in Boston. We’re big fans of their services like free shipping, rock-solid warranties, complimentary ring check-ups, and diverse payment plans.  

Some might think their return window is a bit short, but their accessible website and insightful blog more than make up for it. Their dedication to ethically sourced jewels places them high on the list for those of us shopping with a conscience in Boston’s lively scene. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Brilliant Earth. 

2. Joseph Gann Jewelers 

rose cut diamond engagement ring in yellow gold setting

Location: 387 Washington St, Boston, MA 02108, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.6 Stars

Since 1933, Joseph Gann Jewelers in Boston has been a beacon of trust and excellence. They’re renowned for their extensive experience and stunning collection of gemstones and metals. They offer everything from timeless heirloom pieces to innovative contemporary designs. 

What impressed us about this jeweler is their commitment to individualized customer service. They go the extra mile to educate their clients about the stories and intricacies behind each piece.  

Added perks like one-on-one consultations, reliable shipping, and flexible return policies elevate the shopping experience. Their website, enriched with invaluable information and insights, ensures that every customer feels confident and connected to their chosen pieces. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Joseph Gann Jewelers. 

3. Boston Jewelers and Manufacturers  

oval cut diamond engagement ring in yellow gold setting

Location: 7th Floor, 333 Washington St suite 710-713, Boston, MA 02108, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars

If you’re looking for top-notch jewelry with a touch of history, Boston Jewelers & Manufacturers is the go-to place. Based in Boston, they’ve been the gold standard (pun intended) for quality jewelry for a long time. 

What makes Boston Jewelers & Manufacturers special is their eye for detail and commitment to only the best quality. They check every gem and metal they use to make sure it’s top-notch. Their jewelry collection has a bit of everything – from classic pieces that remind us of old times to trendy, modern designs. 

But it’s not just about selling jewelry for them. They go the extra mile by teaching customers about the story and craftsmanship behind each piece. They offer personal meetings, trusty shipping, and easy return options to make shopping a breeze. Plus, their website is packed with helpful information to help you pick the perfect piece that means something to you. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Boston Jewelers and Manufacturers. 

4. DePrisco Diamond Jewelers 

emerald cut diamond halo engagement ring

Location: Jewelers Exchange Building, 333 Washington St 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02108, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.6 Stars

DePrisco Diamond Jewelers in Boston is renowned for its outstanding artistry and detailed jewelry creations, with engagement rings being a highlight. 

They focus on providing personalized services for their clients. We were impressed with their skills in restoring old family gemstones, carrying out detailed repairs, and their top-notch refinishing. 

Additionally, they provide accurate jewelry evaluations, making sure their customers experience a complete jewelry journey with them. Their consistent dedication makes them a top choice for those seeking the perfect engagement ring in Boston. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: DePrisco Jewelers. 

5. DeScenza Diamonds  

round halo engagement ring in white gold setting

Location: 387 Washington St, Boston, MA 02108, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.6 Stars 

Since 1915, DeScenza Diamonds in Boston has been known for its trustworthiness and top-notch quality. They’re famous for having a wide variety of beautiful gemstones and precious metals. They deal with both old, cherished jewelry and new, modern designs. 

What makes DeScenza Diamonds special is how much they care about their customers. They educating their clients about the history and details of each piece of jewelry. 

Customers get to have special meetings where the staff helps them personally. They also have good options for getting what you buy delivered to you, and if you need to return something, they will help you with that as well. They have a comprehensive website so that anyone buying from them can feel confident and connected to what they’re choosing. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: DeScenza Diamonds. 

6. Laura Preshong Ethical Fine Jewelry 

oval cut cluster diamond engagement ring

Location: 558 Tremont St, Boston, MA 02118, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars 

Laura Preshong Ethical Fine Jewelry is well-known for making engagement rings and jewelry with a focus on being eco-friendly. They’ve always been about using materials that are good for the planet, and their designs show this dedication. Their handmade rings are both beautiful and made in a way that’s good for the environment. 

In their collection, you’ll find many lovely and responsibly-made engagement ring styles. If you want something special, they can make custom jewelry just for you. 

All their jewelry is certified, meaning it’s made the right way and of high quality. They also help their customers learn more about jewelry through their website and helpful staff. 

When you buy from Laura Preshong, you’re not just getting a pretty piece. You also get great services like free shipping, easy returns, regular check-ups for your jewelry, and free size adjustments. They make sure you have a great experience from start to finish. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Laura Preshong. 

7. Boston Diamond Studio  

marquees diamond engagement ring

Location: 333 Washington St #226, Boston, MA 02108, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars

Established for generations in the heart of Boston, Boston Diamond Studio has built a stellar reputation as a beacon of trustworthiness and dedication. This family-operated business is renowned for its commitment to customer satisfaction and integrity.  

Their website is well-structured and you can seamlessly browse through their extensive collection of engagement rings. All of their pieces reflect both timeless elegance and modern sophistication. 

Boston Diamond Studio offers a wide variety of options to suit different budgets, so everyone can find a piece that matches their personal story. They also offer great perks like easy 30-day returns, a long-lasting quality promise, multiple payment methods, the option to create custom jewelry, and quick free shipping. Shopping at Boston Diamond Studio means you’re choosing top-notch quality and outstanding service. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Boston Diamond Studio. 

8. Cynthia Britt Custom Jewelry 

sapphire and diamond engagement ring

Location: 45 Newbury St #305, Boston, MA 02116, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

Cynthia Britt Custom Jewelry is known for making unique, one-of-a-kind jewelry, especially engagement rings. Although they have a limited selection online, what they do display is of top quality, and it captures the brand’s skill and style. Every item they make is done with great care, focusing on unique and special designs. 

Apart from selling beautiful jewelry, Cynthia Britt also offers various other services. They adjust old family jewels to fit new settings, fix and shine up old rings, re-string pearls, and give expert advice on a jewelry’s value.  

We liked how professional they are, how affordable their items and services are, and how friendly their team is. If you’re looking for special jewelry, Cynthia Britt Custom Jewelry is an ideal store to check out.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: Cynthia Britt Custom Jewelry. 

9. E.B. Horn Jewelers 

platinum antique style engagement ring

Location: 429 Washington St, Boston, MA 02108, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars 

If you’re looking for a jewelry store that values educating and guiding its customers over just selling, E.B. Horn Jewelers is a top choice. This family-run business has a longstanding reputation in the jewelry world and is known for its trustworthiness. 

At E.B. Horn Jewelers, the emphasis is on unique, custom-made designs crafted by their talented artisans with extensive experience. Their partnerships with top-notch designers mean they offer a wide variety of styles, from classic diamond solitaires to modern micro-prong designs. You can explore their collection both online and at their physical location. 

E.B. Horn Jewelers also has several customer-friendly features, such as a trade-up option, free shipping, a lasting warranty, complimentary ring maintenance, and various payment plans. We were disappointed that their return policy is shorter than some others, but overall their products and services make up for it.  

To book a consultation, check their website here: E.B. Horn Jewelers. 

10. Barmakian Jewelers  

oval hidden halo pave diamond engagement ring

Location: 333 Washington St, Boston, MA 02108, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.6 Stars 

Barmakian Jewelers truly stands out for its wide array of jewelry options, ranging from everyday pieces to extravagant ones meant for special moments. Their strong commitment to sustainability shines through in their engagement rings, made from recycled materials and ethically sourced diamonds.  

This environmentally-conscious approach sets Barmakian Jewelers apart in the jewelry market, making them a prime choice for those who prioritize eco-friendliness. 

A detail from Barmakian Jewelers that we found to be quite unique is the special signature jewelry box that accompanies each ring. Though it might seem like something insignificant, it emphasizes the brand’s commitment to excellence. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Barmakian Jewelers. 

11. Hannah Florman Fine Jewelry 

round starbust style engagement ring

Location: Newbury St, Boston, MA 02116, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars 

Hannah Florman Fine Jewelry at the Brownstone has rapidly become a name synonymous with exquisite artistry in jewelry. While they might not have been around as long as some other establishments, their store at the Brownstone is a favorite for those searching for a vast array of engagement rings, from timeless classics to contemporary masterpieces. 

Every piece at Hannah Florman reflects a unique narrative, blending vintage charm with modern elegance. We truly appreciate their ethical stance, especially regarding their carefully sourced materials and commitment to providing top-quality, ethically produced options. 

What sets Hannah Florman Fine Jewelry apart is their genuine dedication to their clientele. Their emphasis on superior craftsmanship, ethical sourcing, and above all, customer satisfaction, resonates deeply with us. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Hannah Florman Fine Jewelry. 

Wrapping Up  

Buying an engagement ring in Boston is not just about choosing a piece of jewelry; it’s about investing in a symbol of love and commitment. Boston offers a mix of historic charm and modern elegance, with a plethora of jewelers catering to diverse tastes and budgets.  

When buying the perfect ring, make sure your selection resonates with both your personal story and the rich tapestry of the city.

Jewelry Guide