10 Best Stores to Buy Engagement Rings in Baltimore

Choosing the perfect engagement ring in Baltimore is more than a purchase; it’s a love story milestone. Baltimore boasts a variety of esteemed jewelers known for their craftsmanship and authenticity. 

Here are twelve premier Baltimore stores for engagement rings and why they’re the best in the business. 

1. Brilliant Earth (Aliceanna St) 

a woman wearing a three-stone diamond engagement ring

Location: 1429 Aliceanna St. Suite 200, Baltimore, MD 21231, United States 

Customer Reviews: 3.6 Stars

Brilliant Earth, with its strong ethical foundations, is fast becoming the go-to for sustainable jewelry lovers. Popular for their ethically sourced and environmentally friendly engagement rings, they’re carving a significant niche in the jewelry market. 

What sets Brilliant Earth apart is their dedication to creating personalized engagement rings that mirror the uniqueness of each relationship. They pride themselves on prompt deliveries, with many of their custom rings being available in just a few weeks. We found their ready-to-wear collection impressive, offering a diverse range of elegant choices for those on a tight timeline. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Brilliant Earth. 

2. REEDS Jewelers (Perry Hall) 

double halo diamond engagement ring on the woman's ring finger

Location: 8200 Perry Hall Blvd Space 2115, Baltimore, MD 21236, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars

What makes REEDS Jewelers truly shine is their ability to fashion customized engagement rings that align perfectly with individual preferences. They work quickly, with most of their tailor-made rings being ready for pick-up in under three weeks. We were impressed with their on-site collection of ready-to-wear rings, serving up a vast array of options for those in a bit of a time crunch. 

When we compared prices with some prominent Los Angeles-based jewelers, REEDS Jewelers emerged as a more budget-friendly option. Their prices are competitive because they sell directly to customers, avoiding extra costs from middlemen. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: REEDS Jewelers. 

3. Stephen Page of Baltimore (Fleet St) 

blue sapphire engagement ring in yellow gold setting

Location: 2226 Fleet St, Baltimore, MD 21231, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars

Over the years, Stephen Page Baltimore has carved a niche for himself with unmatched craftsmanship and impeccable customer service. Diving into his collection, we found a mix of uniquely crafted pieces that cater to both traditional and contemporary tastes. 

For those in search of something truly distinct, Stephen offers personalized services, making sure that your vision is beautifully realized. Every creation from Stephen Page Baltimore underscores his dedication to quality and authenticity. 

Stephen’s commitment goes beyond just crafting; he’s keen on guiding customers, ensuring they’re equipped with the knowledge to make informed decisions. Alongside his artistry, he offers an array of services like detailed consultations, adjustments, and care advice to keep your pieces in pristine condition. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Stephen Page of Baltimore. 

4. Lakein’s Jewelers of Hamilton (Harford Rd) 

Emerald Solitaire Engagement Ring

Location: 5400 Harford Rd, Baltimore, MD 21214, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars

Lakein’s Jewelers of Hamilton, a distinguished name in Baltimore, has long been the go-to for couples seeking that perfect engagement ring. Their online presence allows clients to browse their diverse collection from the comfort of their homes. 

We found their range of engagement rings to be vast, accommodating different tastes and budgets. Whether you’re drawn to ageless classics or modern flair, Lakein’s has something for everyone. Beyond their stunning pieces, they also provide easy returns, lasting warranties, bespoke jewelry crafting, and prompt delivery. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Lakein’s Jewelers of Hamilton. 

5. Bijoux Jewels (Wyndhurst) 

pink sapphire and diamond ring

Location: 316 Wyndhurst Ave, Baltimore, MD 21210, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars

Tucked away in a charming location, we came across Bijoux Jewels and were instantly captivated by their handcrafted engagement rings. We noticed that while their online gallery isn’t massive, it’s thoughtfully curated, truly capturing their impeccable craftsmanship. Every ring felt like Bijoux Jewels poured heart and soul into it, making each piece feel truly special. 

But it wasn’t just their rings that caught our attention. Their personalized approach really sets them apart. From revamping old family treasures and resetting those precious gems, to expertly polishing vintage rings, restringing beloved pearls, or giving spot-on appraisals, it felt like Bijoux Jewels really knew how to make us feel taken care of. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Bijoux Jewels. 

6. JRC Jewelry Center (Sulphur Spring Rd) 

emerald and diamond engagement ring

Location: 1605 Sulphur Spring Rd # E, Baltimore, MD 21227, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars

Known for its refined elegance and meticulous craftsmanship, JRC Jewelry Center is a beacon for jewelry enthusiasts. But what truly drew us to JRC Jewelry Center wasn’t just their breathtaking products. It was their warm approach, genuinely focused on understanding and catering to each customer’s unique desires. We were touched by the care they offered – from breathing new life into cherished heirloom gemstones to ensuring our pieces were in perfect shape with their expert repair and refinishing services. 

With their spot-on jewelry appraisals and a commitment to delivering a full-fledged jewelry experience, we can confidently say that JRC Jewelry Center feels like a trusted friend in the quest for that perfect ring. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: JRC Jewelry Center. 

7. Radcliffe Jewelers (Pikesville) 

diamond halo engagement ring in rose gold setting

Location: 1848 Reisterstown Rd, Pikesville, MD 21208, United States 

Customer Reviews: 5 Stars

Radcliffe Jewelers isn’t just another jewelry store; it’s an institution known for its top-notch engagement rings and genuine dedication to its craft. This family-driven business has a stunning collection, with every ring showcasing the creativity and skill of their artisans. And with partnerships with big names like Tacori and Gabriel, whether you’re into classic beauty or modern flair, they’ve got it all. 

But what set our Radcliffe experience apart were the little extras. Think about the ability to level up your ring, the no-cost shipping, their rock-solid warranty, and the ongoing care for your cherished piece. Even if their return policy feels a bit tight, one look at their detailed website and you’ll find all the guidance you might need. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Radcliffe Jewelers. 

8. Samuelson’s Diamonds and Estate Buyers (Quarry Lake Dr) 

oval diamond engagement ring on the ring finger

Location: 2800 Quarry Lake Dr Suite 240, Baltimore, MD 21209, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars

Samuelson’s Diamonds and Estate Buyers is family-run establishment that’s been turning moments into memories with their remarkable engagement rings for years. They’re dedicated to not just selling jewelry but also offering heartfelt experiences. 

Their collection is vast, from timeless classics that never go out of style to the latest trends that cater to the modern bride and groom. They make sure that each piece is as unique as the person wearing it. 

What truly sets Samuelson’s apart, though, is their unparalleled customer service. Whether you’re in search of a bespoke piece, need some tender loving care for your cherished ring, or just some expert guidance, they’ve got your back. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Samuelson’s Diamonds and Estate Buyers. 

9. Nelson Coleman Jewelers (Towson) 

alternating diamond and sapphire ring

Location: 307 E Joppa Rd, Towson, MD 21286, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.9 Stars

Located in Towson, Maryland, Nelson Coleman Jewelers is a go-to spot for those looking for the ideal engagement ring. While not every piece makes it to their website, what’s on display showcases their impeccable design and artistry. 

Every item at Nelson Coleman is crafted with the buyer’s specific wishes in mind, guaranteeing that each ring is as distinctive as its wearer. This bespoke approach does mean no return or refund options, but that’s a standard practice in custom-made jewelry. 

One aspect that truly impressed us was their attention to presentation. Engagement rings from Nelson Coleman come in a beautifully designed box, further reflecting their commitment to perfection, making them a top pick for an extraordinary jewelry purchasing experience. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Nelson Coleman Jewelers. 

10. Smyth Jewelers (Timonium) 

three stone round diamond two tone engagement ring

Location: 2020 York Rd, Timonium, MD 21093, United States 

Customer Reviews: 4.8 Stars

Smyth Jewelers in Timonium is rapidly making a name for itself with its top-notch jewelry designs. Although they’re relatively new compared to other jewelers, they’ve become a go-to spot for a mix of traditional and modern engagement rings. 

Each ring at Smyth has its own special charm, offering both classic and fresh styles. What stands out to us is how dedicated they are to getting their materials the right way, especially their lab-created diamonds, which combine excellent quality with responsible sourcing. 

But what truly defines Smyth Jewelers is their commitment to their customers. They prioritize top quality, honesty, and always aim to make their customers happy. 

To book a consultation, check their website here: Smyth Jewelers. 

Wrapping Up  

Baltimore, with its rich history and vibrant cultural tapestry, offers a unique backdrop for those embarking on the journey of selecting an engagement ring. From traditional to contemporary designs, the city’s jewelers encapsulate both craftsmanship and sentiment.  

So, whether you’re drawn to the charm of a vintage piece or the allure of a modern gem, Baltimore provides an unparalleled experience in finding a ring that speaks to your heart. 

Jewelry Guide